Pensions are not the number on the statement.
The most expensive mistake I see in divorce settlements involves pensions — specifically, treating them as if the number printed on the annual statement is what they're worth.
It almost never is.
A defined-benefit pension — federal FERS, military, state employee, old corporate plans — is a promise to pay money in the future. To value it today, you have to translate "money in 2042" into "money in 2026." That translation involves the participant's age, life expectancy, retirement eligibility, the plan's COLA provisions, and a discount rate. Get any of these wrong and you can be off by six figures.
A few specific things lawyers without financial training routinely miss:
Marital coverture. Only the portion of the pension earned during the marriage is divisible. The formula is months of marital service over total months of service, applied to the benefit at divorce — but courts in different jurisdictions apply it at different dates. Virginia uses the date of separation. Maryland uses the date of divorce. The difference can be years of accrual.
Survivor benefits. A federal employee can elect a survivor annuity for an ex-spouse, but only if the COAP (Court Order Acceptable for Processing) says so explicitly. If it doesn't, the ex-spouse's stream of payments dies the day the employee does. I have seen settlements where the survivor benefit was worth more than the support.
The COLA. Most federal and military pensions include cost-of-living adjustments. Most state plans do, too. A pension valued today without COLA assumptions baked into the present-value calculation is undervalued — usually by 15 to 25 percent.
The early-out option. Some plans let an employee retire early in exchange for a reduced benefit. If the employee plans to take it, the present value falls. If the ex-spouse can choose the timing of their share independently, the present value rises. The order of operations matters.
The number on the statement is what the employee would get if they stopped working today and waited for the normal retirement age, with no COLA, no survivor, and no further accrual. None of those things are true. A proper valuation accounts for all of them.
If your spouse has a pension and your settlement is built on the statement number, you are negotiating against the wrong figure.